Imagine receiving almost $80 million following three successful Security of Payment adjudications, only to be ordered to repay more than $26 million.

That was the position facing Martinus Rail Pty Ltd (Martinus) following a dispute with Qube RE Services (No 2) Pty Ltd (Qube) concerning works undertaken on the Moorebank Intermodal Terminal Project in Sydney.

In Qube RE Services (No 2) Pty Limited v Martinus Rail Pty Ltd [2026] NSWSC 717, the Supreme Court of New South Wales enforced arbitral awards requiring Martinus to repay approximately $26.4 million to Qube, notwithstanding that the amounts had previously been paid pursuant to adjudication determinations under the Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW) (SOPA).

The decision highlights an important distinction between the right to receive payment under SOPA and the ultimate contractual entitlement to retain that payment.

How did an $80 million payment become a $26 million liability?

Between 2023 and 2024, Martinus obtained three adjudication determinations under SOPA requiring Qube to pay amounts totalling approximately $80 million in connection with works undertaken on the Moorebank Intermodal Terminal Project.

Qube complied with those determinations but continued to dispute the contractual entitlement of Martinus to substantial portions of the payments.

The parties subsequently pursued arbitration to determine their respective rights and liabilities under the construction contracts.

A central issue concerned whether certain claims made by Martinus were barred by contractual time limits. Qube contended that Martinus had failed to comply with the contractual requirements for submitting those claims and was therefore not entitled to the amounts claimed.

The arbitrator, the Honourable Robert McDougall KC, determined certain issues separately from the balance of the dispute.

In May 2026, the arbitrator found that a number of claims were barred by the relevant contractual provisions. On 4 June 2026, an arbitral award required Martinus to repay approximately $26.4 million, inclusive of interest.

Can money paid under SOPA be recovered?

Qube subsequently commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court of New South Wales seeking enforcement of the arbitral awards.

Martinus opposed enforcement, arguing, among other things, that requiring repayment of amounts previously received under SOPA would be contrary to the public policy underpinning the legislation.

SOPA is designed to maintain cash flow within the construction industry by providing contractors and subcontractors with a mechanism for obtaining progress payments without waiting for lengthy contractual disputes to be resolved.

However, section 32 of SOPA preserves the rights of parties to pursue their contractual entitlements through subsequent proceedings.

Justice Peden rejected the argument that enforcement of the arbitral awards would undermine the operation of SOPA, recognising that the legislation contemplates that amounts paid following adjudication may subsequently be adjusted following the final determination of the parties’ contractual rights.

The Court also rejected the argument that the arbitral awards should not be enforced because other issues remained unresolved in the arbitration.

Although the arbitration was continuing, the partial awards had finally determined the particular issues referred to the arbitrator for separate determination and were capable of enforcement.

Importantly, Martinus had also raised an argument that section 34 of SOPA rendered the relevant contractual time bars unenforceable. That issue had not been determined as part of the separate questions and remained open in the arbitration. However, the Court found that this did not prevent enforcement of the partial arbitral awards.

The Supreme Court therefore entered judgment in favour of Qube for approximately $26.4 million, together with further interest and costs.

The dispute did not end there

Following the Supreme Court’s decision, Martinus sought a stay of enforcement pending an application for leave to appeal.

Importantly, the proposed appeal concerned the refusal to stay enforcement of the judgment, rather than the decision to enforce the arbitral awards.

On 25 September 2026, the NSW Court of Appeal granted a conditional stay in Martinus Rail Pty Ltd v Qube RE Services (No 2) Pty Ltd [2026] NSWCA 204.

The Court required Martinus to pay approximately $26.43 million into Court within 14 days, representing the outstanding judgment amount after deducting $8,027.95 recovered by Qube through garnishee orders.

If Martinus failed to comply with that condition, the stay would lapse.

The Court of Appeal did not determine whether leave to appeal should be granted or whether the proposed appeal would succeed. Nor did the granting of the stay establish that Qube had recovered the judgment amount.

Why contractual time bars matter

A significant aspect of the dispute is that the arbitrator ordered repayment after finding that a number of claims made by Martinus were barred by contractual time limits.

Construction contracts commonly require contractors to provide notices of variations, delays, extensions of time and additional costs within prescribed periods.

Where compliance with those requirements is a condition of entitlement, a failure to provide the necessary notice within time may prevent the contractor from recovering amounts that might otherwise have been payable.

The dispute demonstrates that obtaining payment through adjudication does not necessarily overcome those contractual requirements.

For contractors and subcontractors, this reinforces the importance of complying with contractual notice provisions throughout a project, even where payment is subsequently pursued through SOPA.

For principals and head contractors, the decision confirms that payment pursuant to an adjudication determination does not necessarily prevent them from pursuing recovery through subsequent contractual proceedings.

This distinction is particularly important on major infrastructure projects, where disputed variation and delay claims can involve substantial amounts.

What does this mean for the construction industry?

The decisions offer practical lessons for contractors and principals alike.

Contractors should not assume that amounts received following adjudication are beyond challenge. Where their underlying contractual entitlement remains disputed, those payments may be subject to subsequent claims for repayment.

Equally, principals who consider that an adjudication determination has resulted in an overpayment should carefully assess their contractual rights and the remedies available to recover that amount.

However, a party’s intention to pursue those remedies does not ordinarily relieve it of its immediate obligation to comply with an adjudication determination.

The distinction between statutory payment obligations and final contractual entitlements should therefore form part of a party’s litigation strategy from the outset.

An interim payment, not a final one

The outcome is consistent with what SOPA was designed to do.

A fundamental feature of SOPA is that an adjudication determination is interim in nature. It establishes an entitlement to payment without finally determining the contractual rights of the parties.

In Probuild Constructions (Aust) Pty Ltd v Shade Systems Pty Ltd [2018] HCA 4, the High Court confirmed that SOPA is “not concerned with finally and conclusively determining the entitlements of parties to a construction contract”. Its purpose is to ensure that contractors receive prompt payment, leaving disputes about their ultimate contractual entitlements to be determined separately.

Importantly, section 32 of SOPA preserves the rights of parties to pursue those disputes through court proceedings or arbitration. Any amounts previously paid under SOPA must be taken into account, and orders for repayment may be made where appropriate.

This distinction was central to the Martinus decision. Although Martinus received payment under the adjudication process, those payments did not prevent the arbitrator from subsequently determining that certain claims were contractually barred and ordering repayment. The partial arbitral awards were final and binding in respect of the issues decided, notwithstanding that the wider arbitration remained ongoing.

The decision reinforces the fundamental distinction that an entitlement to receive payment under SOPA is not necessarily an entitlement to retain that payment once the contractual rights of the parties are determined.

The Bottom Line

The Qube and Martinus dispute demonstrates that success in a Security of Payment adjudication does not necessarily resolve the parties’ underlying contractual dispute.

The $26.4 million judgment highlights the importance of complying with contractual notice requirements and understanding the potential consequences of subsequent litigation or arbitration.

The decision also highlights the importance of choosing the appropriate course when pursuing a payment dispute. Where a claim involves substantial contractual issues and there is no immediate need to secure payment, commencing proceedings under the contract may, in some circumstances, be more commercially advantageous than pursuing adjudication under SOPA, particularly where the dispute is likely to require final determination in any event.

Ultimately, SOPA operates on the principle of pay now, argue later. A contractor may be entitled to receive payment under an adjudication determination, but whether it is entitled to retain that payment may be determined in subsequent proceedings.

Menu

Search Paradise Charnock Hing

The Paradise Charnock Hing website is not compatible with Internet Explorer. Please use a modern browser such as Chrome, Firefox, Edge, or Safari for the best experience.